4 Disadvantages of Reroofing A Shingle Roof in Florida

blog post 4 Disadvantages of Reroofing A Shingle Roof in Florida

Can I reroof a shingle roof in Florida?

Reroofing over existing shingles may seem like an easy and cost-effective solution to a damaged or aging roof. However this is not something we recommended at RIG Roofing. To be clear, reroofing means installing a new layer of shingles on top of old ones.You can imagine some of the issues this might cause. For example, the additional weight of the new shingles may cause structural load complications. Additionally all underlying problems with the existing roof are covered up (i.e. mold, leaks, etc.) and can no longer be fixed. In many cases it is against Florida building codes to reroof over an existing shingle roof. That’s why we always recommend removing the old shingles and installing a fresh new roof. This provides a more durable and long-lasting solution for homeowners.

Is it possible to install new shingles over existing shingles in Florida?

If you are asking if it’s legal in Florida to install new shingles over existing or old shingles. Yes and No. The answer isn’t black and white. Below we give you a breakdown of the Florida Building code when it comes to reroofing shingles over shingles.

If any of the following conditions apply, you are not allowed to apply a new layer of shingles to a roof unless you remove all previous roof coverings down to the roof deck.

  1. The current roof or roof covering is wet, has deteriorated to the point that it cannot serve as a foundation for new roofing, or both.
  2. If the roof's current material is asbestos-cement tile, wood shake, slate, clay, or rock.
  3. When there are already two or more applications of roof coverings to the existing roof.
  4. The current roofing has blisters.
  5. If the existing roof will be used for attachment for a new roof system and compliance with the provisions of Section 1504.1 (building code regarding wind resistance and roofing materials) cannot be met.

So You're Saying There's a Chance

While it's possible, and sometimes legal to reroof a shingle roof under certain conditions, it is never something we would recommend at RIG Roofing. We get it, no one wants to spend unneeded money on their roof. Roofs are not fun or exciting and you only see them when you’re outside. However, what your roof lacks in excitement, it makes up for when it comes to protecting your family and belongs from the Florida heat, humidity, storms, and pests. So, you see, your roof has a pretty important job.

What Are The Disadvantages of Reroofing?

  • Reroofing can cost you more money in the long run.

One of the primary reasons reroofing can be more expensive is due to the additional labor and material costs involved. When reroofing, the old shingles are left in place and a new layer of shingles is installed over the existing roof. This may seem like a simple and cost-effective solution, because If the underlying damage is not addressed, it can lead to more costly repairs down the line, such as the need for a full roof replacement.

  • Reroofing can void the warranty of your new shingles.

An outstanding warranty can make new shingles very appealing. When you are guaranteed a quality product it reassures your money is well spent. However, layering new shingles over existing or damaged shingles can void the manufacturer's warranty.

  • Reroofing adds weight to your roof.

It kind of goes without saying but a double layer of shingles is going to be twice as heavy as one layer. The heavier load on the roof structure may cause problems with ventilation and insulation. To accommodate the additional weight of the new layer of shingles, extra roofing materials, such as underlayment and flashing, may need to be added. Not all homes are able to bear the weight of two sets of shingles. Always check your structure’s capabilities before starting a project that will add additional weight to your roof.

  • Additionally, the process of reroofing requires more labor and time as the roofer needs to take extra care to ensure the new shingles are properly laid over the old ones.

At RIG Roofing we have completed thousands of projects and we always recommend tearing off all roofing materials, down to the decking, before installing new shingles. This ensures all leaks, and damage are exposed and remedied before installing the new roof. Consequently you start off with a sound roof foundation, quality materials, and superior workmanship. Quality is important to us at RIG Roofing, in fact we back every new residential roof we install with a 10 year workmanship warranty and 1 year of preventive maintenance.

See the difference hiring RIG Roofing makes when it’s time to replace your roof.

Contact Us to schedule a free roofing estimate and we’ll send one of our roofing experts out to explain your roofing options along with special financing offers. Don’t put off having a roof that protects your home and family. Reach out today.

RIG Roofing - Reliable Florida Roofing Contractors Franchising Nationwide

R.I.G. Roofing is Florida’s Most Trusted Roofing Contractor

Free Residential & Commercial Roof Assessments | Repair or Replacement


If you’ve got roof problems, let R.I.G. Roofing be your lifetime solution. We are a faith based, family owned roofing contractor offering Free Roof Estimates throughout central Florida. After your roof assessment you can sit down with our roofing specialist who will walk you through their findings and recommendations while answering any questions you may have. If you’d prefer less in-person contact, we can leave our findings and estimate at your door and follow up with you via phone call. Most roof installations are completed in just one day and come with our unmatched 10 – 20 year workmanship warranty and 5 star customer service.

Reliable Roofing Contractor
Residential & Commercial Roofing
On-Time Roofing Appointments
Always Free No-Obligation Estimates
Workmanship & Manufacturer Warranties
Emergency Roofing Services Available
Years of Experience
Request A Free Roof Assessment
or Ask Us A Question
Are You A New or Current Customer
How Can We Help You?
Message / Project Details

Your Local Roofing Company: R.I.G. Roofing

R.I.G. Roofing is proud to offer reliable and honest roof repair and replacement services to residential and commercial customers throughout the United States. Our home office is in Winter Haven, Florida; with satellite offices in Lakeland, Tampa, & Port Charlotte. View our entire service area and call our office1 (863) 294-4477 or send us a message to schedule an appointment today. We can't wait to hear from you!